I am not a lawyer or an accountant but I have to disagree with AndrewD. I disagree that there is no risk. Imagine somebody falls through a soft floor and sues for $500,000, which has happened. We are in court at least once per month typically for evictions and we are sometimes countersued. In a recent case, a tenant refused to sign for the title that we were supposed to transfer to her, and now she is suing us for refusal to deliver title. I do not want to be the defendant personally and have that on my record even though a case like this is minor. I don’t want to be personally responsible for the larger situation.
In another case, a tenant filed a lawsuit against me and a park manager personally. My attorney sent a motion to dismiss to the judge and it was dismissed immediately because the LLC should have been the defendant.
Not all lawsuits are trivial. Until you know what if feels like to have a 7 figure lawsuit filed against you, you may not appreciate the benefit of paying $100 to form a LLC.
I disagree on the fact that incorporating draws double taxation. You can elect subchapter S status and taxes are passthrough.
You don’t know if ValentineP makes $25,000 per year or $10,000,000 per year and the tax structure would vary. Depending on how much he makes it may be disadvantageous or not to form a company, hire himself, and choose the proper mix of paying salary versus distribution. I can assure you that the ratio varies based on the 2 income levels.
You don’t know if ValentineP is worth $25,000 or has $10,000,000 in assets including real estate, cash, stocks, and businesses. If he was in the latter category he would not want to risk all his assets because of a lawsuit on only one of those assets. Thus, they must be kept separate.
I do agree that for some people it is easy to research this and figure out the tax and legal implications on their own and form a company or Corporation on their own, but you cannot assume every person out there has the expertise that you may have to be able to do this research. Also, for some people, time is precious and it is worth it to pay a few $100 extra to have guidance or full service incorporation from their attorney or CPA.
Lastly, because I am not an attorney or CPA, it is not legal for me to provide advice in this matter to ValentineP, but the fact that he asked means he wants guidance. Thus, the only people he can go to to satisfy his want would be an attorney or CPA.